The kids we lose is a documentary scrutinizing the channel from school to prison.
The National Center for Learning Disabilities (2017) declared that fourth-grade students with low reading proficiency are more likely to be incarcerated than students who are reading proficiently.
It is a strong statement, and one can wonder why and how? Before reading this article, if you have not done so, please read the Part 1/2 of “The Kids We Lose” by Dr. Ross W. Greene (Click Here)
What is happening to Johnny?
Johnny is handled by the CPI (1) trained personnel from the playground to school. Once in school, Johnny is brought to a safe room. From there, Johnny is watched by the behavioral specialist and/or an adult until he regains his composure.
Dialogue
Johnny: I hate this place, I want to play. I don’t want to go to class!
Adult: I will put my watch on. You will have to be calm for one minute. I will restart my watch until you have a safe body!
Finding himself in the safe room with nothing else than a mark on the floor. Johnny is reeling!
Johnny: I don’t care, I want to play…
This will last until Johnny can respond to three random commands
Adult: Johnny, touch your knees, touch your elbow, and touch your head.
At this point, Johnny responds to the requests
Adult: Please stand or sit on the mark on the floor for one minute, and then you will be able to get out of this room.
Johnny responds to request. As a result, he can get out of the safe-room.
It is at this point that counseling and/or consequences occur. In the meantime, Johnny would have missed precious class time. Consequently, Johnny will start to fall behind academically due to behavioral issues.
My experience
I worked in education for 15 years, but last year was my first year working in an elementary school. I must admit thatI recognize some of the scenes from the documentary,”the kids we lose.”
How is the child responding to these treatments?
We could expect that a child would understand the pain he endured and would not want to do it again? However, he does not stop misbehaving!
In fact, the documentary “the kids we lose” shows that students become accustomed to punishment. As a result, they become immune to sanctions and continue to misbehave, losing faith in adults and the system in the meantime.
According to Dr. Greene, the reason is simple. They can’t! They are not equipped to solve social, emotional, and behavioral challenges!
Early detection of the problem
Dr. Greene pointed out that the dysfunctional responses from a child can be detectable very early on. The documentary related the experiences of parents who noticed that their child was not responding appropriately.
It went on to show parents looking for solutions while witnessing frequent uncontrollable outbursts, disrespect for boundaries, and aggressivity from their child.
Are parents always aware of a potential problem?
Nonetheless, some parents thought that these behaviors were normal. It was only when schools alerted them that they could, at times, acknowledge that their child might have a problem.
On the other hand, some parents sought out the services of a psychologist, special education, guidance counselors, and doctors. They sadly mentioned that nothing worked.
Moreover, children become discouraged and believe that nothing and no one will be able to fix them. They know, they can see how they behave compared to their peers. The documentary displays their despair and how they are resigning themselves to their fate.
Consequences for these children
They often end up going from school to prison because a child who had not learned to deal with his emotions will continue to misbehave.
Schools often call them ¨repeat offenders.¨ Unfortunately, growing up, they would have faced many punitive consequences resulting in growing anger and disrespect for authority. Who would blame them? What did the authorities do for them? Sadly, some children will turn to drugs or alcohol abuse to mask their pain, while others will turn to violence. Sorrowfully, all behaviors leading to prison.
Consequences for their peers, parents and educational staff
In 1993, the U.S Department of education enabled the integration of students in need of special education into the mainstream educational environment (Hossain, 2012).
With mainstreaming came exposing all children to potential outbursts from students lacking the cognitive skills necessary to regulate themselves.
Therefore, these misbehaviors became visible to all peers and educational staff. The documentary “The kids we lose”, mentioned that teachers who are at the forefront of these behaviors feel ill-equipped to deal with violent outbursts. They also want to protect the other children in the class and therefore ask for back up when incidents occur.
These backups can be behavioral specialists, administrators, special education teachers, guidance counselors, autism specialists, or school psychologists.
However, teachers are concerned and fear for the safety of other students who can get bit, pushed, or yelled out. They are also concerns for the child who cannot control his behavior, as the teacher knows that this child might be punished one way or the other.
How are peers internalizing all of this? Did we ask them?
Teachers are also concerned about teaching their curriculum so that all students can make progress. These interruptions often take precious time away from instruction, leading teachers to worry.
They worry for kids who suffer from uncontrollable outbursts because they are missing instructional time while having to deal with cognitive issues. Additionally, they worry for all kids who will not have the opportunity to finish the curriculum.
Solution
I am all heartedly with Dr. Green regarding the CPS method(See my posts on “Lost at School” part 1/2 and part 2/2)
If you believe that we can help the children at risk to fully integrate the educational system and get the education they rightfully deserve, then we all need to spread the word out. Please share my website eLearning-sofun.com!
All together, we can make a difference!
Thank you, Dr. Greene, for leading us in educating the child not only academically but also in his social-emotional development!
Watching the documentary
Unfortunately, PBS had the rights to show this documentary until 6/8/2020. Therefore, I linked an interview made about the movie. However, the movie is available on Amazon: The Kids We Lose.
The Kids We Lose is a 90-minute documentary film about the human side of being a child or student with behavioral challenges, and the struggles faced by parents, educators, staff in facilities, mental health clinicians, and judicial and law enforcement professionals in trying to ensure that these kids receive the help they need.
Warning! the documentary is emotionally difficult to watch. It is shown children with violent outbursts and with harsh punishments for consequences.Please do not watch the interview below or the documentary, the Kids we Lose with your children!
Final thought
The documentary could become a platform to engage in discussions with your child. You could ask him what he is witnessing in his school and how he feels.
As a result, an open discussion might shed some light on what is happening in your child’s school and how he is fairing in his daily environment.
How did it go?
I would like to hear from you, and please send your comments, questions on the link below.
You can also download my free book: “10 fun, yet effective technics for your child to read with pride and joy! 😉
In the meantime, parents and children, eLearning-sofun is for you! If you have questions after reading this post, please send them below. We will answer every question.
“Learning is intelligence having fun!”
(1) CPI technics have been established by the crisis Prevention Institute offers nonviolent crisis intervention training designed to teach best practices for managing difficult situations and disruptive behaviors.
Students learn how to identify at-risk individuals and use nonverbal and verbal techniques to defuse hostile or belligerent behavior. To know more click here
The kids we lose, a documentary scrutinizing the channel from school to prison.
The National Center for Learning Disabilities (2017) declared that fourth-grade students with low reading proficiency are more likely to be incarcerated than students who are reading proficiently.
About the documentary
Dr. Ross W. Greene, through his non-profit organization, “Lives in the Balance,” funded the documentary “The Kids We Lose.” To this end, Dr. Greene collaborated with the independent production company “Lone Wolf Media”. This company is one of the leaders in factual entertainment.
The documentary graphically shows the evolution of children who are not fitting in the school system. The most compelling evidence of children not fitting in is that they won’t or can’t abide by school regulations.They rebel, and they act as if the world should be revolving around them.
In fact, they behave as if nothing else matters but having it their way!
Let us take an example!
For instance, Johnny doesn’t want to come back from recess. The bell rings, and children start to line up, but Johnny keeps playing with his cars on the playground.
Dialogue
Teacher: Johnny, it is time to line up, let’s go! (Johnny continues playing disregarding the invitation to line up).
Teacher: Johnny, put your car in your pocket, and please line up.
Johnny: I want to play!
Teacher: I understand, but it is now time to line up. You can play again during next recess. Come on, Johnny, you will be late for your class. Look, everyone is going in, and your teacher is waiting for you!
Johnny:Yelling and crying. I don’t want to, I want to stay here and play.
Teacher: I will have to call for Mrs. Summary (Assistant principal) if you do not come with me.
Johnny:Now rolling on the ground. I don’t care, I want to play and I don’t want to go to class! And, I hate my class and I hate everybody!
At this point, the Assistant principal and the behavioral specialist come and using CPI technics (1), bring Johnny back to school.
What is happening to children like Johnny?
They are commonly called “children at risk” because they usually do not perform to the expected academic level due to behavioral challenges.
As a consequence, they might not graduate from High School while suffering through 12 years of schooling.
Through this documentary filmed across North America, Dr. Greene documents the methods used to bring these children “back in line”.
Sadly, the documentary portrays children out of control and adults using different avenues to contain them.
Thereupon, the methods went from restraining the child, to send him back home, to in school or out of school suspensions, to handcuffing children, to involving the police, to placing children in solitary confinement or locked-door seclusion, to using a paddle to spank them.
This documentary is very difficult to watch!And it is even more difficult to realize that no better solutions are found and applied to change the course of these children!
PODCAST from Dr. Ross W. Greene
Following the documentary, Dr. Greene explained his reactions after hearing from people who watched the video. Click here
Next post: What is happening to Johnny?
On the next post, we will discuss “What is happening to Johnny?”
What to expect!
How a child is responding to these treatments?
Why the child doesn’t stop misbeaving and what are the subsquent consequences?
The solutions!
And finally the link to the documentary.
In the meantime, parents and children, eLearning-sofun is for you! If you have questions after reading this post, please send them below. We will answer every question.
“Learning is intelligence having fun!”
(1) CPI technics have been established by the crisis Prevention Institute offers nonviolent crisis intervention training designed to teach best practices for managing difficult situations and disruptive behaviors.
Students learn how to identify at-risk individuals and use nonverbal and verbal techniques to defuse hostile or belligerent behavior. To know more click here
The subject of this article, homeschooling and statistics were requested by Maple Steely. Thank you, Maple! As promised, here are the answers to your question.
Introduction
Most of this article is based on the “General Facts, Statistics, and Trend” by Dr. Ray D. Brian from the National Home Education Research Institute (NHERI). Research published on March 23, 2020.
Disclaimer: This article relates to the findings of Dr. Brian. Therefore, even though I will not mention Dr. Brian’s name throughout the summary of the findings. They belong to Dr. Ray D. Brian. However, I will cite other authors.
Who are the parents homeschooling?
To begin with, religion or the educational background of the parents does not influence homeschooling. Therefore, parents from all walks of life homeschool.
However, a study by Noel, Stark, and Redford from 2013 mentioned that 32% of homeschool students are African American, Asian, Hispanic, and others. This percentage is trending upward each year .
How many students are homeschooled in the US?
Students in grades K-12 who are not attending a physical school are considered as homeschooled. In 2019, 2.5 million students or 3.5% of school-age children were homeschooled.
However, 3.4 million U.S adults, at one point were home for their studies. Therefore, if we add these numbers, 5.9 million Americans lived through homeschooling.
Why do parents choose to homeschool?
I know that I decided to homeschool my son when his first-grade teacher announced that he had to wait for the others in the class to catch up to his reading level.
You see, my son benefited from parents who read to him every day and taught him the basics of reading before entering first grade.
Consequently, he reached expected reading proficiency for a first grader in March.
As a result, my son was supposed to wait for the other students to reach his level by June.
It meant that he was not going to be challenged in reading from March to June. This was not acceptable to us, parents!
However, I am sure that parents have their own stories leading them to homeschool their children.
For instance,the reasons could be religious, wanting more than what public schools have to offer, choosing the curriculum, or providing a safer environment. All valid reasons when we want the best for our children!
State Standardized tests vs. NAEP
Homeschooled students would only have to take State Standardized tests if the state requires it.
Therefore, the State Standardized Tests reports on reading proficiency will only include participating homeschooled students.
However, the National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP) is only voluntary. In fact, 4th, 8th, and 12th grade students are assessed on different subjects including reading.
So yes, homeschool students perform 15 to 30 percentile points above public-school students on standardized academic achievement tests.
Singularly, this gap is even more important for African Americans. In 2015, these children scored 23 to 42 percentile points above their peers in public schools.
Due to these results, colleges are seeking homeschooled students as they also have higher SAT and ACT scores.
Dr. Rachel Coleman, the Executive Director of Coalition for Responsible Home Education (CRHE), is not denying the fact that homeschooled students are well above average in reading than their peers but wonders if it is true in all subjects?
Over the years, in 1988, 1991, 2000, 2005, 2007, few studies were conducted to determine the proficiency level of homeschooled students.
If you want to know more about the results, please click here.
As the dates show, these studies are not conducted regularly. According to Coleman, only the state of Arkansas tests annually homeschooled students. Nonetheless, all of these reports point out to one issue.
The Homeschool Math Gap
The results from the chart are a bit dated, but they illustrate the point.
Homeschooled students have a higher level of reading proficiency than their peers in public schools, with 86% vs. 80%.
However, in math, the tendency is reversed. Homeschooled students have a lower level of math proficiency than their peers in public schools, with 63% vs. 69%.
The implication of these results
Homeschooled students are less likely to go into a Science,Technology, Engineering, and mathematics (STEM) field than their counterparts.
7.7% and 5.1% of homeschooled students go into STEM programs compared to 17.8% and 15.6% of students in public schools.
Students in public schools also choose STEM fields more so than students in private schools with 17% and 14.3%.
Final thought
The data collected from homeschoolers are sporadic and lack consistency because not all states require testing.
Also, the NAEP testing renders a global image of the proficiency level of students nationwide; besides, it is only voluntary.Moreover, NAEP uses a sample of 4th, 8th, and 12th-grade students, not all students.
According to Jesse Card, as of yet, there is no national standard for the evaluation of homeschooled students
Call to action
Should we advocate for a homeschool national standardized test?Consequently, parents of homeschoolers would have accurate results about the level of proficiency of their children in all areas, i.e., Science, math, and reading.
I would love to hear from you on this subject. So please leave your comments or questions below.
Thank you for your trust, andby clicking on this link: www.eLearning-sofun.com, you can download my free book: “10 fun, simple yet effective technics for your child to read with pride and joy!”
Dear parents, today we are sharing information about the expectations of the 21st-century learning framework(21st-CLF). Furthermore, we are exploring the implementation of Social-Emotional Learning (SEL) in schools, which is the latest baby in education.
What’s in it for you?
4 reasons for understanding (21st-CLF) and SEL:
1 – Be aware of the functioning of the 21st– century educational system through 21st-CLF.
2 – Have a vision of what is expected for your child to accomplish during his 12 years of schooling with 21st-CLF.
3 – Understand what an educator is talking about when he mentions SEL.
4 – Implement SEL at home.
21st-Century Learning Framework (21st-CLF)
The Center for Curriculum Redesign (CCR) who brought together international organizations, jurisdictions, academic institutions, corporations, and non-profit organizations, including foundations, designed the elements a student should learn for the 21st century.
Here is a representation of students’expectations throughout his formal education.
Let’s break 21st-CLF down!
Knowledge:What we know and understand. The Common Core State Standards initiative in 2010 defines what students should know at each grade level throughout the United States. It is from there that educators derive their curriculum and lesson plans. Students are taught these subjects explicitly in class, such as ELA, mathematics, etc.
Skills:How we use what we knowthrough creativity, critical thinking, communication, and collaboration. This requires a higher level of involvement from the students. It is where they apply what they learn in different settings. This implies that students must be self-directed. Educators include projects or working in groups for students to develop these skills. Students, in turn, are assessed to determine the development of their thought processes.
It is where SEL fits in
Character:How we behave and engage in the world. Until recently, schools have been using a top-down approach when dealing with behaviors. The teacher set the rules, and the students had to behave. It is changing with the recent introduction ofSocial-Emotional Learning (SEL).
Social-Emotional Learning is meant to support students in recognizing and managing their emotions. We know that students who are not ready emotionally to learn will not learn, and no punishment for not paying attention or misbehaving will change this. On the contrary, it will probably make it worse. Let’s think about this: being punished for not feeling emotionally ready to learn? Hmm!
Therefore, educational organizations created a Core SEL Competencies.
There are 5 Core competencies to consider in Social-Emotional Learning (SEL):
Self-awareness: For a child to recognize his emotions
Self-management: Have the ability to manage his emotions
Social awareness: Develop empathy
Relationship skills: Establish healthy relationships with peers and adults
Responsible decision-making: Being able to evaluate his behavioral choices and potential consequences.
I was able to see Social-Emotional Learning in action for students ranging from Kindergarten to second grade. The SEL teacher combined mindfulness, yoga, and movements.
A group of students, led by their teacher, came to the SEL classroom. They sat quietly, cross-legged on a colorful carpet. The Social-Emotional Learning teacher was waiting for them calmly.
Self-awareness
Once seated, students were guided to self-awareness. The teacher asked: Do you have enough space? Are you comfortable? Are you ready to start?
After everyone was comfortable, she asked each one of them how they felt today.
A thumbs-up (I am great),
A thumbs to the side (I am ok)
A thumbs -down(I am not good)
The student explained why he felt this way and the other students had to sit quietly listening. Once a child expressed his feelings, the others had to respond with a comment showing empathy, such as I am sorry you are not feeling well today!
Yoga
The teacher followed up by guiding students through yoga poses. The emphasis was on movement, breathing, and being in the moment. During that time, they practiced social awareness.
For instance: who is next to me? Am I bothering him while doing my poses? What should I do if I do not want to be next to this student? How should I communicate this problem with my peer and my teacher? How can I go to the bathroom or get a drink without disturbing the group? When is the right moment to express my needs while in a group?
The teacher addressed concerns as they arose, thanking the students for asking these questions as they showed concern for others as well as awareness. Their thought process awaken to the consequences their actions could have on others.
Finally, the teacher read a story where characters faced moral challenges. While reading, she was asking questions such as: How does he feel? What would you do? Is he happy?
These interactions, led by the teacher, allowed students to develop listening skills, empathy, and problem-solving.
Guided meditation
At the end of the class, the teacher led the students through a short guided meditation. The teacher had a Tibetan singing bowl in front of her and used it to start. All students were seated on the carpet listening to soft music and the teacher’s soothing voice. At the end of the session, she rang the Tibetan singing bowl. Students waited until the end of the sound to get up quietly, line up, and go back to class.
My observations on SEL
I could feel a difference in the level of tension in the classroom from the time students arrived to when they left. They came from their classes, cafeteria or back from recess where the pace was faster, their emotions running amok, and then the calm, mindfulness and self-awareness. A time for them to pause, refocus, and re-center on themselves!
Kids enjoyed this time, even the otherwise rumbustious students. I also noticed that these skills did not stay in the Social-Emotional Learning classroom. They spread out into their classroom, the cafeteria, and recess! At home too maybe?
You can do SEL at home!
It was wonderful being part of this experience, but you can implement this at hometoo. Set a time with your family to pause and reflect on your emotions!
You do not need a Tibetan singing bowl or know how to guide meditations. Many guided meditations from the internet can guide you. In our search engine, you can type Guided meditation for children or guided meditation for kids.
If you want to go further and read stories emphasizing perseverance, acceptance, true-self, dealing with emotions, seeing the world through different lenses and kindness.
Some suggestions thanks to Publishers Weekly:
Abracadabra!: The Magic of Tryingby Maria Loretta Giraldo, illus. By Nicoletta Bertelle (Magination), shines a light on perseverance and the discovery of one’s inner magic. Ages 4–8.
All Are Welcome by Alexandra Penfold, illus. by Suzanne Kaufman (Knopf), follows a group of diverse children through a day at their school, where everyone is welcomed, supported, and encouraged, and friends from a wide variety of cultures share their traditions with each other. Ages 4–8.
Amina’s Voiceby Hena Khan (S&S/Salaam Reads). Amina, a Pakistani-American Muslim struggles with whether she should hide her true self to try and fit in and be more American like her best friend has done, as she copes with middle school dramas and a devastating vandalism attack on her local mosque. Ages 9–up.
Being Edie Is Hard Todayby Ben Brashares, illus. by Elizabeth Bergeland (Little, Brown, spring 2019). A girl imagines transforming into different animals to deal with the challenge of managing her emotions at school.
Being You by Alexs Pate, illus by Soud (Capstone, Oct.). Two children discover that they have a choice about how the world sees them in a story that delivers a message of love, self-discovery, and optimism.
For more options click on the Publishers Weekly <==
Thank you, and please leave a comment below! Your opinion, concerns, or questions matter to me!
You can also download my free book: “10 fun, yet effective technics for your child to read with pride and joy! 😉
Learning is intelligence having fun!
Stay tune for our next post:
SEL is a good step in the right direction. Children learn to recognize and manage their emotions but are children really heard?
We will see on our next post how you and your child can go further than SEL in establishing a protocol of conflict resolution where both parties are heard and misbehaviors magically dissolve!
P.S:Amazon links are affiliated. We perceive a small commission if you use the Amazon links. The commission keeps us diffusing free content. Thank you for your support! 😉
After having achieved my lifelong dream of becoming a Doctor in Educational Leadership, I set myself to create, eLearning-sofun’s website. Jean-Marie is dealing with technical support and made it all possible! Thank you darling!
The method will apply fun, simple, yet effective technics for your child to read with pride and joy!
The 2019 National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP) revealed that 2 out of 3 students in 4th and 8thgrade were NOT reading at grade level.
Yes the statistics are alarming!
Therefore my goal is to to help mitigate this situation.I want for every child to apply reading principles by increments he can handle.
Unfortunately,children who cannot read or read undergrade level suffer not only academically but moreover emotionally.
I have been teaching for 15 years as a special education teacher and a French teacher. Therefore, I realized with sadness that a lack of literacy skills affects not only the child’s academic performances but also affects his life.
Your child needs time, a step-by-step method, and a “magic” ingredient for him to find pride and joy in reading!
I created a method based on neuroscience and pedagogyfor children to access the principles of reading!
He is not the only one! Interesting facts! If in 2019, we take any classroom in the United States,out of3 students, approximately 2 would NOT be reading at grade level.
Each year the National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP) assesses students in 4th, 8th and 12th grade on their level of reading proficiency.
We will only discuss 4th and 8th grade results. Therefore, the 2019 results showed that 35% of students in 4th grade and 34% of students in 8th grade were at or above proficiency level in reading!(1) (2)
Furthermore, the 2019 results for Students with Disabilities revealed that 12% of students in 4th grade and 9% in 8th grade were at or above proficiency in reading. (1) (2)
Meaning that for students in special education, less than9 out of 10 students were not reading at grade level in 4th grade while in 8th grade, more than 9 out of 10 students were not reading at grade level.
Finally, the 2019 results for English Language Learners revealed that 10% of students in 4th grade and 4% of students in 8th grade were at or above proficiency in reading. (1) (2)
Meaning that for English Language Learners,9 out of 10 students were not reading at grade level in 4th grade, and about 10 out of 10 students were not reading at grade level in 8th grade.
Yes the statistics are alarming. But Keep reading, hope is around the corner!
Your child can read!
Each child has its own time frame to learn to read! Some can read at 3 years-old, while others need more time.
In school, it is expected for a child to reach certain milestones at each grade level. But your child is unique, with his abilities and life experiences.
How can your child learn to read?
Your child needs time, a step-by-step method, and a “magic” ingredient for him to find pride and joy in reading!
When your child struggles, many unwanted emotions come to the surface, such as fear, anger, or withdrawing.
These emotions have outside manifestations
Fear can lead to a lack of self-confidence. This will, in turn, get your child stuck, not wanting to explore new things for fear of not being able to do them, to look stupid or to be mocked.
Anger is a major break to progression because with anger comes refusal to explore new things. If you hear your child say,
“this is stupid, leave me alone”, or you see him storm out of the room when it is time to read; it is not because he doesn’t want to but because he knows that he can’t, and it makes him furious.
Withdrawing is the other side of the coin of anger. Is your child not showing interest, feelings, or emotions when it comes to reading? Or does he, with a passive reluctance, comply with your requests?
Well, it means that your child surrounded and accepted defeat. In his head, he thinks that he is not getting it and will never get it, therefore, he goes through the drill, hoping to get it over it quickly.
Have you noticed any of these 3 manifestations in your child?
If yes, this website “eLearning-sofun” is for you and your child.
You will be able to download my free book “10 fun, simple yet effective technics for your child to read with pride and joy!”
These 10 easy technics will allow your child to get started on the path of reading proficiency.
This book has for objective to engage you and your child on the path of reading.
We are looking forward to reading your comments and questions.